Did You Choose the Wrong Topic for Your Blog?

Admit it. You’ve asked yourself this question at least once since you started to blog. Maybe even twice.

Perhaps you ask yourself this question every single time you write your heart out, only to get little to no traffic. No comments. You’re not getting the kind of feedback you were hoping for when you decided to blog about your topic.

To make matters worse, you’ve done all the things popular bloggers say to do, like publishing great content and commenting on other popular blogs and getting accounts on Twitter and Facebook, but no matter how hard you work, no matter how many different techniques you try, nothing is working.

So you ask yourself…

Where did I go wrong?

Is it possible that you have chosen a topic for your blog that no one gives a damn about?

Are you simply wasting your time trying to keep your blog alive?

Well… let’s find out.

Signs you may have chosen the wrong topic

The truth is that no one can can say for sure if a blog topic is bad or not, but there are certain signs. You can get by with one or two, but if you find yourself doing the majority of these mistakes, then you might be in trouble.

Take a look through this list to see which ones apply to you:

1. Your topic is not popular enough. Here’s how to test the viability of your topic: if there’s a How To For Dummies book already written about it, the topic is probably popular enough.

2. You get comments from less than 1% of your visitors. Bare minimum, you should get comments from 1 in 100 visitors. That’s about twenty comments for two thousand unique visitors. At least. If you’re not even in the 1% range, chances are your topic is not engaging enough.

3. You’re writing about incompatible topics. Let’s say you have a blog about self-publishing and photography. The two are incompatible. The ones who are fans of your photography couldn’t care less about your posts on self-publishing, and vice-versa. The thing is, you’re not pleasing anyone with this. Try blogging about topics that work well together.

4. You’re in a niche of (almost) one. Here’s the thing. If there’s no one else who blogs about the same topics and has a large following, then you’re probably writing about the wrong topic. If there are no Facebook Pages, Groups, or books written about this topic, then it’s not going to be popular enough. You’ve managed to find the kind of niche no one cares about.

5 You’ve run out of new topics to write about. If you’ve been blogging for less than a year, and you already have to rehash the same old topics over and over again, you niche may be too narrow.

6. You own less than five books on your topic. Sometimes, you can find a perfectly viable topic, but it’s not viable for you. The simplest way to tell? Look over on your bookshelf, and count how many books you own on the topic. If it’s fewer than five, it probably means you’re not passionate enough about it. Bloggers who are successful over the long term are obsessed with their topic, and they’ve read everything they can get their hands on.

7. When you have to write a new blog post, it feels like a chore. If you’d much rather go fishing, even though you don’t like the taste or smell of fish, than finish your blog post, then you may have chosen the wrong topic. If it happens occasionally, it’s okay — we all have off days — but if none of the blog posts you write get your heart pumping, you need to find a different topic, quick.

So, does this mean you have to give up on your blog?

No, not really.

Anybody can look at this list and talk themselves into giving up if that’s what they feel like doing

The truth is, many blogs, mine included,  succeed despite being guilty of nearly every warning sign on this list, and some blogs that seem to get everything right flop.

You never know, unless you try.

But what should you do if you’re worried you chose the wrong topic?

My advice is to think. Do a bit of research using the warning signs above as guideposts, and ask yourself what it all means.

Becoming a popular blogger isn’t about luck. It’s about having the right strategy and the discipline to employ it. It’s about working your butt off to make it happen.

Get these right, be passionate about your topic, and you can carve yourself a niche.

Mindset Tip: Either find a way or make one.

Keep your head high, do some thinking, work your butt off, and most importantly, believe in yourself. If you’re determined, and you persevere, you will get there eventually.

And when you do, it’ll all be worth it.

There’s a new blog post on our patreon:

It’s kind of frustrating, isn’t it? Having to scroll for a minute and a half through hundreds of comments on some posts just so you can say what you thought about it.

It’s even more frustrating when your own posts aren’t getting many comments. Sometimes it’s a comment or two. Sometimes none. Occasionally, it seems Lady Luck smiles upon you and you get a few of your readers to say something.

But never dozens or hundreds of comments like some of the other blogs out there.

Maybe it’s all about luck, maybe there’s some trick, some tactic, and you can’t help but wonder…

Am I doing something wrong?

What can I do to get more comments?

Well, first of all it’s not magic. Or trickery. Secondly, let’s see if we can do something about it.

In order to get more comments, one must understand how they work.



15 thoughts on “Did You Choose the Wrong Topic for Your Blog?

  1. Your sixth point made me smile because at one point my books about ageing got completely out of control and I had to make myself stop buying them. But there’s one more possibility: that you have chosen a topic ahead of its time. Today you may be the only person in the world blogging on this topic, but in five years time it will become a hot topic, and you will be regarded as a leader in your field. I’ve been in that position twice, and it’s not particularly comfortable.

    Liked by 5 people

    1. TinaMarie, do you make an ask for readers at the end of each book review? That may give readers a comment direction. They may not know you want comments on your reviews. Many reviewers don’t.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. This point about blogging for happiness is undersold. Yes, we want value and eyeballs-on, but our motivation to do anything with regularity and steady improvement depends on the satisfaction return-on-investment.

      Athena Minerva, you are rare in your self-awareness, not your motivation.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I picked my topic on the basis of how much I love it. The only thing I struggle with is the topics WITHIN the main theme. I want to bring readers posts they will like and I noticed that some topics such as fashion get many more hits than topics such as music. So I try to make sure I blog about fashion as much as I can, even though I personally prefer talking about music.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I like the Mindset Tip. I believe it is the Secret Sauce every successful entrepreneur uses to fuel her/his work.

    There may be no wrong blogging topic except wrong for the blogger’s primary purpose. If the goal is monetary, then popularity must factor. If it is reaching a personal goal, then asking for and offering support on others related blogs will help. If reaching other people like you is the goal, like crafting or parenting, commenting on related sites and joining groups will let others know you are there.

    Maybe a “wrong” topic just means your mirror is dirty or a realignment is necessary.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.